Cheap flights from New York to Key West
2 airport pairs connect New York and Key West: LGA–EYW and EWR–EYW. American Airlines, Delta Air Lines and United Airlines fly nonstop. The cheapest fare found was $150, on LGA–EYW.
New York to Key West: every airport pair compared
| Route | Nonstop airlines | Flights a week | Time in the air | Cheapest fare found |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York LaGuardia → Key West LGA–EYW | — | ~2h 45m (est.) | $150 | |
| Newark Liberty → Key West EWR–EYW | United Airlines | — | ~2h 45m (est.) | $153 |
Each route has its own guide with airlines, connections, the return flight and how to get into town.
New York to Key West fares by month
Cheapest one-way fare found: $150 for January 2027 on Frontier Airlines (1 stop).
- Nov ’26$314
- Dec ’26$157
- Jan ’27$150
Cheapest one-way fares per month of departure in the Aviasales price cache, found . Fares change by the hour: the live fare is shown when you search. Cheapest of all the airport pairs above, per month.
Arriving at EYW
After you land in Key West
- From Key West airport (EYW) into Key WestLanding late, with luggage or in a group? A pre-booked driver meets you in arrivals at a price fixed when you book.Airport transfers in the United States via Kiwitaxi
We may earn a commission if you book through these links, at no extra cost to you. How we earn.
New York to Key West: frequently asked questions
How much is a flight from New York to Key West?
From $150 one-way, the cheapest fare found (LGA–EYW, January 2027; found 16 November 2026).
Which airports can I fly between New York and Key West?
2 airport pairs: LGA–EYW and EWR–EYW.
Which airlines fly nonstop from New York to Key West?
American Airlines, Delta Air Lines and United Airlines.
What is the cheapest month to fly New York to Key West?
January 2027, at $150 across all 2 airport pairs.